GTA 6 Kill or Spare Arnold: What Happens in Hey Arnold!
Hey Arnold! is a Chapter 1 story mission for Brian, and it ends with one of the first real choices in Grand Theft Auto VI. With Arnold on his knees at the end of a dock, you decide whether Jason pulls the trigger or lets him walk.
Short answer: killing Arnold pushes Jason toward a Hardened criminal profile. Sparing him keeps Jason Restrained and may leave the door open for Arnold to turn up again later. The rest of Chapter 1 plays out the same either way.
How the mission gets you there
Arnold is the middleman behind Donnie's drug runs, and he has stopped answering Brian. Brian wants to know why, so the three of you go looking for him.
Drive Brian to the liquor store, then head south down the causeway.
Cal traces Arnold's phone. Follow the route out to the radar station with the aerostat floating over it.
Arnold tells Brian their business is over, and things fall apart. When he runs, the objective switches to Chase Arnold.
Stay on his tail through the yards. Tap the lock-on button the game shows you to keep the camera fixed on him while you run. He ends up trapped at the end of a dock with nowhere left to go.
The choice: kill or spare
There's no menu here. Jason has his gun on Arnold, and what you do with it is the decision.
What you do | Result |
|---|---|
Shoot Arnold | He dies on the dock. Jason's criminal profile moves toward Hardened, and Arnold is gone for good. |
Lower the gun and let him go | Jason's profile stays Restrained. Arnold is still alive and could show up again later in the story. |
Wait and do nothing | Arnold says he'll swim for it and jumps in the water. This works out the same as sparing him. |
On our playthrough we shot him. Straight after, the game warns that indiscriminate violence counts toward a more violent criminal profile, which shows how closely it's tracking you even this early.
Should you kill or spare Arnold?
Spare him if you want to keep Jason's profile clean, or if you want every chance of seeing Arnold again later.
Kill him if you're playing Jason as the harder of the two. It doesn't fail anything or lock you out of any missions.
One kill on its own won't ruin your profile. Our criminal profile guide explains how the levels move and how to pull Jason back toward Professional.
After the choice
Both outcomes end at Brian's house, where you meet his friend Kenton, a treasure hunter who has dive work for you. Brian also drops your pay for the Arnold job into Jason's mailbox. Missions can't be replayed while the story is in progress, so choose with that in mind. Every decision we've found so far is in our choices and consequences guide.
