The Most Overrated Brawlers in Brawl Stars, and Why the Hype Doesn’t Tell the Full Story

Just because a brawler is popular doesn’t automatically mean they’re the best choice for every player. Some brawlers have built an incredible reputation over the years, but once you actually start using them, you quickly realize they demand far more skill, better matchups, or very specific maps than people usually mention.

That doesn’t make them bad. Far from it, they’re still incredibly powerful. The problem is that many players expect them to carry every single game, and that’s where expectations stop matching reality.

This guide looks at seven of the most overrated brawlers in Brawl Stars and explains why the hype around them doesn’t always tell the full story.

Why hype and reality don’t always match

Highlight clips are designed to show the best possible outcome: a perfect jump, a clean team wipe, an escape that shouldn’t have worked.

What those clips don’t show is the hundreds of matches it took to get there, or the specific situation that made the play possible in the first place.

That gap between what looks amazing on video and what actually happens in an average match is exactly where a brawler’s reputation stops matching its real performance.

That gap shows up in the numbers too. Most of the brawlers on this list currently sit lower on our live Tier List than their reputation would suggest, which is a big part of why the hype doesn’t always hold up in an average match.

Edgar

Edgar is one of the most controversial brawlers in the entire game. If you’ve ever watched beginner gameplay, he probably looks unstoppable.

He jumps in close, and his life-steal punches can wipe out unsuspecting players in seconds. It looks incredible, but once you start climbing trophies, things change dramatically.

Experienced players know exactly how to keep their distance. They save knockbacks, they save stuns, and they wait for Edgar to jump in before punishing him immediately.

He can still dominate the right matchup, but he isn’t the automatic win that many new players believe. He’s incredibly matchup dependent, and understanding when not to jump is just as important as knowing when to attack.

Mortis

Few brawlers look cooler than Mortis. The clips are unbelievable: team wipes, impossible escapes, triple kills.

Watching a skilled Mortis player almost makes you want to unlock him immediately, but here’s what those highlight videos don’t show: the hundreds of matches it takes to become that good.

Mortis has one of the highest skill ceilings in all of Brawl Stars. Poor timing, bad positioning, or diving into the wrong target usually ends with you getting eliminated almost instantly.

He’s absolutely incredible in the hands of experienced players, but for beginners, Mortis can easily become one of the hardest brawlers to succeed with.

Dynamike

When you watch professional players, Dynamike looks completely broken. His attacks seem impossible to dodge, his Super deletes entire teams, and his movement tricks are unbelievable.

But actually landing those attacks consistently is much harder than it looks. Unlike many brawlers, Dynamike demands prediction.

You’re constantly trying to guess where your opponent will move next, and against experienced players, missing just a few attacks can completely remove your impact from the match.

He’s extremely rewarding to master, but definitely not as easy as many people think.

Kit

Kit generated enormous hype when he arrived, and for good reason. His unique mechanics made him one of the most talked about brawlers in the game.

But popularity doesn’t always mean consistency. Kit shines in coordinated teams and certain situations, but he isn’t the answer to every game mode or every matchup.

Many players unlock him expecting an instant upgrade to their account, only to realize that getting the most value from him requires good teamwork and smart decision making.

Piper

Piper is another brawler that looks absolutely unstoppable in highlight clips. Landing long range shots and eliminating enemies from across the map feels amazing.

But here’s the catch: missing shots with Piper is incredibly punishing.

Unlike brawlers with wider attacks or faster reloads, every missed shot gives your opponents more opportunities to close the distance.

In the hands of a skilled player, she’s one of the strongest marksmen in the game, but for newer players, mastering her takes patience and excellent aim.

Kenji

Kenji has quickly become one of the flashiest brawlers in Brawl Stars. When everything comes together, he can dive into a fight, eliminate multiple enemies in seconds, and escape before anyone can react.

It’s easy to see why so many players call him overpowered, but that aggressive playstyle comes with real risks.

Choosing the wrong target, diving in at the wrong time, or overcommitting can quickly turn a winning fight into an instant defeat for Kenji.

He rewards smart decision making just as much as mechanical skill. Without both, he becomes far less effective than many players expect.

Crow

Finally, let’s talk about Crow. He has always been one of the most popular legendary brawlers.

His poison slowly drains enemy health, prevents healing, and constantly pressures opponents. He feels incredibly annoying to play against, but many players mistake that annoyance for overwhelming damage.

Crow isn’t designed to instantly eliminate enemies. His strength comes from slowly controlling fights, forcing mistakes, and creating opportunities for his teammates.

If you’re expecting Crow to charge into every battle and carry games through raw damage alone, you’ll probably be disappointed. His true value comes from patience and smart positioning.

Final thoughts

So are these brawlers bad? Absolutely not.

Every single brawler on this list can completely dominate matches when played correctly. The problem isn’t the brawler, it’s the expectations.

Many players unlock these characters believing they’ll instantly start winning more games.

But the truth is that success in Brawl Stars comes from understanding your brawler, choosing the right maps, learning good positioning, and improving your decision making. No brawler can replace those fundamentals.

Before upgrading a popular brawler, ask yourself one simple question: does this brawler actually fit the way I enjoy playing?

The strongest brawler isn’t always the one everyone else is using. It’s the one that matches your playstyle.

FAQ

Does “overrated” mean these brawlers are bad?

No, every brawler on this list can dominate a match when played well. The gap is between how easy they look in highlight clips and how much skill, positioning, or team support they actually require.

Which brawler on this list is hardest to use well?

Mortis and Dynamike both demand the most precision and prediction, so they tend to have the steepest learning curve of the seven.

Is Kit actually weak, or just situational?

Kit currently performs well overall, but he leans heavily on having teammates to attach to and support. His value drops in uncoordinated matches, which is what makes him feel inconsistent despite strong numbers.

Should I avoid unlocking these brawlers?

Not necessarily. It depends on whether their playstyle matches how you like to play, so check our Tier List and Brawlers Database for current performance before deciding.

Related tools & resources

Browse more guides and tools on the Brawl Stars home page.

Compare any of these brawlers head to head with the Compare Brawlers tool.

Check exact stats, gadgets, and star powers in the full Brawlers Database.

See where each brawler currently ranks on the live Tier List.

Not sure who to upgrade next? Try the Upgrade Advisor.